I've only recently tried the MAC Carbon and yeah, I end up with dust all over my face too. But I find the foamy applicators (a little damp) make a huge difference. I can't stand using a brush, the powder gets everywhere. Maybe it's just that my "technique" is bad, whatever, but I never used to have problems like this when I bought the cheap crap several years ago. It's like they're using something different in powder shadow now that they didn't used to, or something. The texture isn't the same. One thing is for sure, the cheap crap never had a decent black until a few years ago. I love MAC's colours, but i think when it's gone I'm going to source out a cheaper solution.
------------------------------------